Interactive Versions of Figures from Paper 'Analysing the Apprenticeship System in the Maghribi Traders Coalition'

Note: Clicking on a plot opens a chosen plot in a new tab. Plots are visualized using WebGL and can be explored using the mouse. Though all modern browsers should have WebGL support (Click to check support for your browser - page opens in a new tab), some may not work (i.e. only show static visualisations). For Firefox you may need to activate WebGL. Chrome worked very reliably during tests. Internet Explorer 11 likewise works but does not render gridlines properly.

An extended version of the paper (including a detailed sensitivity analysis) is covered in the PhD thesis 'Agent-Based Institutional Modelling: Novel Techniques for Deriving Structure from Behaviour' in Subsection 4.2.2 (Page 132 onwards). The corresponding figure numbers from the thesis differ from the book chapter and are shown in parentheses.
Figure 1 (Thesis: Figure 4.7): Number of cheaters with relationship to non-cheater for different Upper and Lower Jah Differences
(red surface: without apprenticeship system; green surface: with apprenticeship system; light blue surface: absolute cheater reduction by apprenticeship system)
    Interactive plot (opens in new tab):         Plot with data values:  
Figure 2 (Thesis: Figure 4.8): Number of cheaters with relationship to non-cheater for different Cheating Probabilities and Lower Jah Differences
(red surface: without apprenticeship system; green surface: with apprenticeship system; light blue surface: absolute cheater reduction by apprenticeship system)
    Interactive plot (opens in new tab):         Plot with data values:  
Figure 3 (Thesis: Figure 4.9): Number of cheaters with relationship to non-cheater for different Observation Quotas and Lower Jah Differences
(red surface: without apprenticeship system; green surface: with apprenticeship system; light blue surface: absolute cheater reduction by apprenticeship system)
    Interactive plot (opens in new tab):         Plot with data values:  
Figure 4 (Thesis: Figure 4.10): Number of cheaters with relationship to non-cheater for different Observation Quotas and Lower Jah Differences for a reduced number of trade interactions
(red surface: without apprenticeship system; green surface: with apprenticeship system; light blue surface: absolute cheater reduction by apprenticeship system)
    Interactive plot (opens in new tab):         Plot with data values:  
Figure 5 (Thesis: Figure 4.11): Number of cheaters with relationship to non-cheater for different Observation Quotas and Lower Jah Differences for a reduced number of trade interactions for 200 agents (all other experiments: 400)
(red surface: without apprenticeship system; green surface: with apprenticeship system; light blue surface: absolute cheater reduction by apprenticeship system)
    Interactive plot (opens in new tab):         Plot with data values: